Consumer Reports Best Mattress for Back Pain 2023 – Buyer’s Guide

It is unbelievable that many individuals suffer from persistent back pains silently. There are many causes for this condition, one of them being the mattress that you choose to sleep on.

Whether you are a stomach, side, or back sleeper, it is vital that you invest in a unit with the perfect firmness that would offer support to the lower and upper back as well as the joints and shoulders.

We understand that finding the ideal mattress for back pain is not a walk in the park, and that is why we have decided to do a detailed review on the consumer reports best mattress for back pain.

Besides analyzing the key features of the products we consider as the top ones, we’ll provide you with a buying guide detailing the factors to consider in your search.

Here we go.

Mattresses for Back Pain as per Consumer Reports: Comparison

Take your time to go through the following brands of mattresses and check out whether any of them has what it takes to make you entirely free from constant back pains.

Here they are.

RankingMattress NameTrialWarranty
1Puffy Mattress101-Night SleepLifetime
2DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress365-Night SleepLifetime
3Awara Organic Luxury Mattress365-Night SleepForever
4Nectar Memory Foam Mattress365-Night SleepForever
5Level Sleep Mattress365-Night SleepForever
6Eco Terra Hybrid latex Mattress90-Night Sleep15 Years
7Helix Mattress100-Night Sleep10-Years
8Birch Natural Mattress100-Night Sleep25 Years
9Tuft & Needle Mattress100-Night Sleep10 Years
10Layla Memory Foam Mattress120-Night SleepLifetime

Here are in-depth reviews of our consumer reports best mattresses for back pain:

1. Puffy Mattress: The Best Mattress for Back Pain

If you are looking for a mattress that can accommodate different sleeping positions, here is an option that you may consider. It is designed such that the stomach, side, back, or combination sleepers would be comfortable on it.

Let’s go deeper into the product.

Product Description

The first feature to look at is the top layer, which features a gel-infused foam. The significance of this feature is that it helps in keeping you cool throughout the year.

Next up is a foam layer that contours to your body’s shape and helps in providing the necessary body cushioning for your comfort.

The base layer comprises a firmer foam, and its combination with the two top layers offers you outstanding back support.

Other Features and Benefits

One thing that makes this product so appealing is the 101-night sleep trial that it offers. During this period, you can test to see whether the unit meets all your preferences. If it doesn’t, you can ask for a full refund of your money.

There is also a lifetime warranty meant to give you peace of mind as you use the product.

With a 4.6 out of five customer rating, it is easy to consider this unit as the best mattress for back pain.


  • Stain-resistant cover
  • Firm base layer
  • Perfect for all types of sleepers


  • Pricey

2. DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Here is another option that individuals prone to back pains would find appealing. This is due to its design that offers support to the midsection while keeping the spine aligned to offer you the comfort that you need.

Check out our brief review of the unit.

Product Description

Let’s start with the gel-infused top foam that does not trap as much heat as other standard foams. This feature offers you the coolness for a comfortable sleep. The cashmere blend cover is breathable and also contributes to the cool nature of the mattress.

The unit then features a stay-put technology that ensures couples sleep peacefully even when one of them fidgets a lot at night. This is due to the individually wrapped coils that minimize motion transfer.

Another thing is that the mattress is relatively lightweight and, therefore, easy to move around.

Other Features and Benefits

With the 365-night sleep trial, you have ample time to gauge the benefits and flaws that this unit brings. Further, it comes with a lifetime limited warranty to boost your confidence in the product.

The high-density gel memory foam provides relief for your pressure points, which is crucial for those suffering from aching joints and backs.


  • Affordable
  • Offers a 365-night sleep trial
  • Relieves the pressure points


  • Not for side-sleepers under 130lbs

3. Awara Organic Luxury Mattress

This is the top organic option to make it to our list. For this reason, your chances of being exposed to potentially toxic substances are significantly reduced. 

Let’s see what this item is all about.

Product Description

The first outstanding feature is the plush Euro-top cover made out of New Zealand wool, which is quite effective in absorbing moisture and keeping dust at bay.

Further, the New Zealand wool is crucial for the cooling aspect plus also plays a part in the unit’s optimal airflow.

Let’s also mention the breathable cotton that gives the mattress a soft feel plus boosts its moisture-wicking properties.

We liked the natural Dunlop latex foam which is thicker and more durable than other standards foams.

Other Features and Benefits

This unit is designed to offer relief on pressure points such as the neck, back, and hips to promote a comfortable night of sleep. Besides that, the neutral spine alignment ensures that your back’s natural curve remains intact.

Also significant is the minimal motion transfer that keeps you comfortable even when your partner shifts around all night long.


  • Durable
  • Minimal motion transfer
  • 100% organic


  • Not for wooden beds

4. Nectar Memory Foam Mattress for Back Pain

With a comfort system that comprises three layers of memory foam, there is reason to believe that this Nectar unit could be the solution to constant back pain.

Before deciding to invest in it, check out what we found out about the mattress after extensive research.

Product Description

First, many customers acknowledge that this product has the right balance of softness and firmness so that you do not end up with a stiff back in the morning.

The next thing worth mentioning is that the memory foam top layer is gel-infused so that there is no heat build-up, which ensures that you remain cool throughout the night. This layer is quilted into a Tencel cover, which is breathable to promote airflow.

Below the top layer is a firmer memory foam to offer the stability that is often missing in other memory foam beds.

Other Features and Benefits

This product has a 365-night sleep trial to enable you to gauge whether it is for you. The lifetime warranty should also be an indicator of the confidence that the manufacturer has in the product.

Lastly, this unit works with all types of frames.


  • Minimal motion transfer
  • Risk-free investment
  • Budget-friendly


  • Lacks the hugging sensation of memory foam

5. Level Sleep Mattress

As the name suggests, this unit has a level sleeping surface. We attribute this feature to the innovative foam topper that comprises firm, soft and medium foams, plus it enhances spinal alignment, which makes it perfect for individuals with back pain.

Let’s see what else there is to this product.

Product Description

Made in the USA, this mattress features the patented three-zone design to offer the right balance of softness and firmness that would be friendly for your back.

Then, the unit has the Energex foam, which adapts to temperature changes so that your nights do not become uncomfortably hot.

Another aspect you are sure to appreciate is that the mattress works with all types of frames, which saves you the hassle of shopping for a specific item.

Other Features and Benefits

This unit is constructed out of premium materials and is Certi-PUR certified as being free from potentially toxic elements for your safety.

Another thing is that the product is designed under the watch of experts so that you end up with the highest quality product.

Lastly, the cover is removable to make it easy to clean.


  • Well-made
  • Has a three-zone design
  • Easy to clean


  • Gives off a funny smell when new

6. Eco Terra Hybrid latex Mattress

This is another eco-friendly option that you ought to consider going for. Further, all the materials used in the construction have the necessary certifications to prove their organic quality and safety for you.

Check out our brief review of the product below.

Product Description

Due to this mattress’s organic nature, you can expect the unit to be entirely free from toxins or polyurethane. So, you can sleep in peace, knowing your health is not compromised.

Then, the materials used are breathable and moisture-wicking to ensure that you do not have a sweaty body as you sleep, for your comfort.

The certified organic wool material used is temperature regulating plus resists dust mites and mildew so that you have a comfortable sleep at night.

Other Features and Benefits

Let’s also mention the pressure-relieving coils that offer your back support plus do an excellent job of absorbing the movements made by your partner.

The other thing is that the unit is available in medium and medium-firm levels so that you can choose the appropriate firmness for yourself.

Lastly, the mattress comes with a 15-year limited warranty to make it a risk-free investment.


  • Non-toxic construction
  • Fantastic edge support
  • Affordable


  • Heavy

7. Helix Mattress

Ever heard of personalized customization? That is what you get with Helix mattresses, whereby the first step in the purchase involves filling out a survey so that you can disclose all your preferences and specifications. With that information, the firm designs a unit that is meant specially for you.

Let’s see what else you get from this item.

Product Description

First, this unit is Certi-PUR certified as being free from all toxins. So, you are relatively safe from potentially harmful elements.

Then, with the many options available, all types of sleepers are likely to find something for themselves, including side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and combination sleepers.

We also liked the unit’s bounce, which individuals who are always changing positions at night would find useful.

Other Features and Benefits

The fact that this is a boxed mattress means that delivery and setup is likely to be a straightforward affair.

Another thing that may please you is a portion of the proceeds is channeled towards charity initiatives.

Lastly, the unit has a 120-day trial and a 15-year warranty for your peace of mind.


  • Non-toxic composition
  • Customizable
  • Has a 120-day trial


  • Too many options available

Read more: IKEA Haugesund Mattress Review: Latest Facts + Guide

8. Birch Natural Mattress

If you are obsessed with finding a mattress with an entirely natural construction, the Birch mattress is an item you may find appealing. This hybrid unit is made out of a combination of eco-friendly materials such as Talalay latex and organic cotton.

Read on and see if this product has what you are looking for.

Product Description

Let’s start with the comfort layer, which offers the ideal balance of comfort, support, and bounce, and we could attribute this aspect to the comfort layer that lies over the pocketed coils.

Further, this mattress has minimal sagging that stomach and back sleepers would find appealing. The firmness is just enough for your spine alignment and hip elevation.

The wool in the comfort layer does an excellent job of moisture-wicking and absorbing the heat your body gives out, which helps in the unit’s overall temperature regulation.

Other Features and Benefits

As for the base, it features a thin layer of wool batting, and this enhances the overall stability of the unit.

The pressure relief that this unit offers for the hips, shoulders, and lower back is commendable. At the same time, the motion transfer is minimal, and this is something that sleeping couples would appreciate.

Other notable features include a 100-night sleep trial, free shipping, and a 25-year warranty.


  • All-natural construction
  • Breathable cover
  • Has a 25-year warranty


  • Too thin for some

9. Tuft & Needle Mattress

Are you wondering whether all the positive reviews about this mattress by Tuft & Needle are genuine? Well, we can tell you that there are a lot of positives that we can draw from this unit. For instance, it is versatile and can accommodate all types of sleepers.

And there’s more.

Product Description

First, this mattress is made up of two layers of foam. The top one is an adaptive foam that comprises graphite that deflects your body heat from you and a cooling gel that traps your body heat to keep you cool.

This medium-firm unit is then breathable to allow for more airflow, which is crucial for tolerable temperatures.

The plush cover is also breathable and contributes to the overall comfortable nature of this mattress.

Other Features and Benefits

This mattress is compatible with most of the bed frames out there, and this makes your shopping more straightforward as you do not have to purchase anything specific.

The 100-night sleep trial and 10-year limited warranty only add to the exciting aspects of this unit.


  • Affordable
  • Plush and breathable cover
  • Versatile


  • Complaints of poor packaging

10. Layla Memory Foam Mattress

Layla is a brand that only came around in 2016, but it has established itself in the market industry in this short while. For this reason, we do not doubt that this is a high-quality mattress that would not let you down.

Our brief review will tell you more about this product.

Product Description

First, this is a flippable mattress that comprises both a soft and firm side. So, we can confidently say that you are getting two firmness options.

Then, the cover is crafted from a polyester blend to give it a plush and luxurious feel.

When you flip the soft side up, the first notable aspect is the comfort layer that comprises copper-infused memory foam to keep you cool. Further, the foam offers plenty of sinkage due to its slow pressure response.

The next layer is the transitional polyfoam layer that absorbs the upper layer’s sinkage to give you a softer landing on the firmer bottom layer.

Other Features and Benefits

With the soft side up, the polyfoam layer offers a solid foundation for the mattress. However, when you flip it to the firm side up, this foam becomes a transitional layer that would be great for your back and hips.

We also liked the minimal motion transfer that ensures you and your partner sleep peacefully even when one of you is restless.


  • Offers great relief from pressure points
  • Flippable
  • Low motion transfer


  • Minimal bounce

Mattress for Back Pain – Buying Guide

Several factors should guide you in your search for the best mattress for back pain. If you get this area right, you will be on the correct path toward finding the right item for the job.

We have discussed these factors below in detail.

The Support

When we talk about support, we can look at it differently. For instance, the unit ought to have sufficient firmness that would maintain your spine alignment.

Additionally, the mattress should also be designed in a way that offers the necessary support for your hips, back, and shoulders.

According to expert research seen by Consumer Reports, a medium-firm mattress would be the best choice for you if you are prone to back pains.

The Construction

If you experience persistent shoulder and back pain, you should consider going for a foam or latex mattress. This fact is backed by a 2010 study that discovered individuals with back pains had more comfortable sleep on such a mattress.

Other types of mattresses that you could try out include air beds, hybrid designs, pillow tops, and water beds.

However, most Americans use innerspring mattresses, which are not the best option for alleviating back pains.


The ultimate goal of investing in a high-quality mattress is to find comfort that is hard to find anywhere else. In general, softer units offer more comfort than firmer ones. This may explain why numerous studies found that individuals with lower back pains slept better on waterbeds and foam mattresses.

Another thing is that if you want to find a unit that offers the ideal comfort, you ought to do the shopping yourself since you know your interests best. Further, it is also vital that you try out the mattress before going home with it.

Try out multiple sleeping positions and see whether the unit offers the desired comfort.


Another thing also worth considering is whether the materials used in the construction have potentially toxic elements. This would ensure that you are not at risk of being exposed to substances that may harm you.

The Brand

There are many brands out there, and some of them tend to give us sub-standard products. So, you should do a background check on the brand and read previous reports on its products. Also, check the customer reviews and what the consumers think about the firm’s services.

Warranties and Sleep – Trials

These two factors help make the product a risk-free investment by allowing you to try it out and return it in case of any issues. Read the terms of returning the product and see whether they are favorable to you.

FAQs on Mattress for Back Pain

As dug deeper into consumer reports of best mattresses for back pain, we came across some queries which we shall attempt to answer in this section. We hope they help in boosting your knowledge of the topic.

Which types of mattresses are the best for back pain?

The units that we consider ideal for back pain include Hybrids, Innerspring, Latex, Airbed, Waterbed, and Foams. Although the units offer different benefits, they would go some way in eliminating the discomfort.

Is the pillow an essential factor?

Yes, it is. This is because the pillow helps elevate the neck and shoulders to the perfect angle that would offer the support you are looking for. So, find a pillow that would work hand in hand with the mattress to provide you with the best support.

The Best – Overall #1

The product that we felt is the best on the list is Puffy Mattress. It may be pricey, but it offers you full value for your money. Besides the physical benefits, the product has a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty.

Final Word

Back pain is something that you can easily ignore until it is too late. If bad comes to worse, you may become completely immobile due to back issues going unattended. Therefore, it is wise if you took the necessary preventive measures early enough.

One way of taking charge of things is by investing in the right mattress that offers the right comfort level. We hope you have taken your time to read consumer reports of best mattresses for back pain because we believe we have touched on everything noteworthy on the topic.

If you take note of everything, nothing should stand in your way of finding the right product.

Was this article helpful?

Suggested Articles